I Judge People Too Quickly—Here’s Why I’m Trying to Stop

I judge people too quickly—often before they even speak. It’s a habit I don’t want but struggle to break. What if I’m missing something? What if I’m wrong?

Photo by Kelly Sikkema on Unsplash

The Instant Verdict: Why I Judge People Too Quickly

I was walking down a crowded street, minding my own business, when I spotted a man in a designer suit stepping out of an expensive car. Instantly, my mind filled in the blanks: Probably arrogant. Probably thinks he owns the world. Probably the kind of guy who talks rudely to waiters. I hadn’t heard him speak a word. I hadn’t seen how he treated people. But in less than a second, I had already decided who he was.

This happens all the time.

I judge people too quickly, even when I don’t want to. I tell myself to be more open-minded, to give people a chance before making assumptions. But it doesn’t work that way. The judgments appear automatically, like a reflex. Before I even speak to someone, I’ve already formed an opinion. Sometimes, I don’t even need to see them in person—just hearing about them, seeing a social media post, or watching how they move through a space is enough.

And let’s be honest: these snap judgments aren’t usually positive. Rarely do I look at a stranger and think, Wow, that person must be incredibly kind, intelligent, and emotionally mature. No. My mind gravitates toward the negative.

That guy’s fake.
She’s trying too hard.
They only care about money.
He’s talking to me just to pass time—he doesn’t really care.

Where does this come from? Why does my brain work like this? And most importantly, is this how I want to see the world?

They say we form first impressions in just a few seconds of meeting someone. But what if it’s even worse than that? What if we’ve already judged them before they even say hello?

As I started paying attention to this habit, I realized it was affecting me more than I thought. It wasn’t just about other people—it was shaping the way I moved through the world, the way I engaged (or failed to engage) with others, and even the way I felt about myself. I was stuck in a cycle of quick, cynical conclusions, and frankly, it was exhausting.

So I began asking myself: What if I’m wrong? What if these judgments are missing something important?

That’s when things started to change.

The Pre-Loaded Narrative: Judging Before We Even Meet

It’s strange, isn’t it? How we can decide who a person is before they’ve even spoken a word to us. It’s not just about first impressions—it’s about the pre-loaded narrative our minds create before an interaction even takes place.

I catch myself doing this all the time. Someone’s name comes up in conversation, and before I’ve even met them, I’ve already made up my mind. Oh, they’re from that industry? Must be superficial. They hang out with that crowd? Probably pretentious. They went to that school? Privileged and out of touch. The person remains a mystery, but my brain fills in the blanks, as if I already know everything I need to know.

This isn’t limited to individuals either. It extends to groups, places, even entire professions. A man in a luxury car? Probably full of himself. A loud group at a restaurant? No manners. A social media influencer posting perfect pictures? Fake. It’s easy—too easy—to put people into boxes before we’ve even had a real chance to understand them.

And the worst part? These judgments don’t always come from personal experience. Often, they’re inherited. We absorb stereotypes from our culture, media, past experiences, and the opinions of others, sometimes without even realizing it. Someone tells us, Oh, that guy? He’s bad news. And just like that, we accept it as truth.

But here’s the problem: we are not impartial observers—we are biased storytellers.

Our brains crave shortcuts. Judging someone quickly saves mental energy. Instead of carefully analyzing every new person we meet, our minds rely on past data, even if that data is incomplete or flawed. We don’t take the time to see the whole picture; we settle for a rough sketch, often one shaded by our own fears, insecurities, and assumptions.

I started noticing how much I was doing this in everyday life:

• Someone driving aggressively? Must be an entitled jerk. (Maybe they’re rushing to a hospital.)

• A friend who hasn’t replied to my message? Probably doesn’t care about me anymore. (Maybe they’re overwhelmed with life.)

• A stranger looking serious? Must be unfriendly. (Maybe they’re just deep in thought.)

How often am I wrong? Probably more than I’d like to admit.

And that’s the dangerous part: when we assume, we stop being curious. Instead of allowing people to show us who they are, we reduce them to a one-dimensional version of the story we’ve already written. We create invisible barriers, pushing away potential friendships, insights, and experiences because we’ve already decided what they’ll be like.

The more I reflect on this, the more I realize: the way I judge others has little to do with them and everything to do with me.

So, what would happen if I loosened my grip on these narratives? If I allowed people the space to surprise me? If I stopped assuming and started observing instead?

I don’t know the answer yet. But I think it’s worth finding out.

The Default to Negativity: Why Most of My Judgments Aren’t Positive

If I step back and analyze my thoughts, a clear pattern emerges—most of my judgments aren’t positive. In fact, they lean toward the negative almost by default.

Rarely do I look at a stranger and assume the best. Instead, my mind instantly highlights flaws, assigning motives and character traits before I have any real evidence. A reckless driver? Probably entitled. Someone speaking too loudly in public? No manners. A friend who cancels plans? Must not value our friendship enough. It’s as if my brain is programmed to assume the worst, painting the world in dull, critical shades rather than giving it the benefit of doubt.

Why Does This Happen?

At first, I thought maybe I was just being realistic. That my judgments weren’t necessarily wrong, just observant. But when I started paying closer attention, I realized something deeper was at play.

1. Negativity Bias: The Brain’s Survival Mechanism

Psychologists call it negativity bias—our tendency to focus more on negative experiences than positive ones. It’s an evolutionary survival tool; back in prehistoric times, assuming the worst could keep us alive. If someone outside our tribe looked suspicious, it was safer to assume they were a threat than to give them the benefit of the doubt. Fast forward to modern life, and this survival instinct is still at work, but now it shows up as unnecessary cynicism.

2. Confirmation Bias: Seeing What We Expect to See

If I believe people are mostly selfish, I will subconsciously filter the world in a way that reinforces that belief. I’ll notice the friend who forgets to check in, but I might ignore the one who consistently reaches out. I’ll focus on the driver who cuts me off but forget about the one who let me merge. Our brains are wired to seek evidence that supports our existing beliefs—and if my belief is that people are disappointing, then of course, I’ll keep finding proof.

3. Fundamental Attribution Error: The Flaw in Our Assumptions

We judge others by their actions, but we judge ourselves by our intentions. If someone is late, they’re irresponsible. If I’m late, it’s because I had a valid reason. If someone speaks bluntly, they’re rude. If I do it, I’m just being honest. This is called fundamental attribution error—the habit of attributing other people’s actions to their character rather than their circumstances.

And this realization hit me hard. How many times have I excused my own behavior while holding others to an impossibly high standard? How often have I judged someone for being inconsiderate when, in reality, they were just having a bad day?

What This Constant Judgment Costs Me

It’s easy to think that judging others only affects them. But in reality, it takes a toll on me—on my mood, my energy, my ability to truly connect with people.

• It drains mental energy – Constantly scanning the world for things to criticize keeps my mind in a cycle of negativity.

• It creates distance – When I assume the worst, I shut down opportunities for deeper relationships. I build walls instead of bridges.

• It makes me less present – Instead of experiencing life as it is, I experience it through a filter of assumptions.

And worst of all? It makes me miss out on the good. While I’m busy noticing flaws, I might be overlooking kindness, humor, and warmth in the people around me.

So now, I have to ask myself: If my judgments are mostly negative, what am I missing? What would my life feel like if I actively tried to assume better, not worse, about the people I encounter?

I don’t know yet. But I think it’s time to find out.

---

---

The Judgmental Mindset as a Defense Mechanism

Lately, I’ve started wondering: Is my judgment of others really about them—or is it about me?

The more I observe my own thoughts, the more I realize that judgment often isn’t just a reaction. It’s a shield. A form of protection. A way to keep myself from getting too close, too involved, or too disappointed.

There’s something comforting about judgment. It creates a sense of control. If I can label people quickly, I don’t have to deal with the complexity of who they really are. If I assume the worst, I won’t be caught off guard when they let me down.

But while this mindset might feel like protection, I’ve started to see that it’s also a trap.

Why Judgment Feels Like Protection

1. It Keeps Me From Getting Hurt
   If I assume someone is fake, selfish, or unreliable, I won’t expect anything from them. And if I don’t expect anything, I can’t be disappointed. It’s a way to emotionally armor myself against letdowns before they even happen.

2. It Gives Me a False Sense of Superiority
   Judgment comes with a built-in ego boost. If I decide that someone is shallow, obnoxious, or naive, I automatically position myself as better. I may not consciously think it, but deep down, it creates a quiet reassurance: At least I’m not like that.

3. It Helps Me Navigate the World More Easily
   Life is messy. People are complex. But if I can categorize someone quickly—good, bad, trustworthy, fake—then I don’t have to waste time figuring them out. Judgment simplifies things. It creates mental shortcuts.

At first glance, this all seems logical. But when I look at it more closely, I realize something important: This "protection" doesn’t actually protect me at all. It limits me.

What This Shield Is Really Costing Me

• I Miss Out on Real Connection
  The more I judge, the less I engage. If I assume people aren’t worth knowing, I never give them the chance to prove me wrong. How many friendships, conversations, and experiences have I dismissed before they even had a chance to develop?

• I Carry More Negativity Than Necessary
  Judgment isn’t just about observing people—it’s about assigning meaning to their actions. And most of the time, that meaning is negative. The more I do this, the more I fill my own mind with assumptions that drain my energy.

• I Don’t Allow People (or Myself) to Grow
  People are dynamic. We evolve. We have bad days and good days. When I judge someone too quickly, I freeze them in place. I decide this is who they are, rather than allowing room for change. And worse—if I’m constantly judging others, I wonder: Am I also holding onto a rigid, outdated version of myself?

So, What’s the Alternative?

I don’t want to be naive. I don’t want to blindly trust everyone or ignore red flags. But I also don’t want to live in a mental space where cynicism wins. So what’s the balance?

Maybe it’s not about abandoning judgment completely. Maybe it’s about shifting from judgment to discernment.

• Judgment is rigid; discernment is flexible.

• Judgment assumes; discernment observes.

• Judgment shuts people out; discernment keeps an open door.

Instead of making snap assumptions, what if I paused? What if I allowed myself to gather more information? What if, instead of deciding who someone is, I let them show me?

It might not be as easy. It might take more effort. But something tells me it would make life a lot lighter.

How to Unlearn Judgment Without Being Naïve

At this point, I know two things for sure:

1. Judging others too quickly is limiting me. It creates negativity, blocks potential connections, and keeps me trapped in assumptions.

2. But I don’t want to be naive. I don’t want to ignore red flags or put blind trust in people who might not deserve it.

So the real question is: How do I unlearn judgment without losing discernment? How do I train my mind to be more open, while still protecting myself from harm?

I’ve been thinking a lot about this, and I’ve started trying a few mindset shifts that help me slow down my snap judgments. They don’t require me to blindly accept everything and everyone, but they do create more space for curiosity over assumption.

1. The Benefit of the Doubt Experiment

A while ago, I started a simple mental exercise. Every time I catch myself making a negative judgment about someone, I ask myself:

"What if I’m wrong?"

That’s it. Just that one question.

• The driver who cut me off—What if they’re rushing to see a sick family member?

• The friend who hasn’t texted back—What if they’re struggling with something I don’t know about?

• The loud person in the restaurant—What if they’re just excited about their conversation, not being intentionally obnoxious?

It doesn’t mean I excuse every behavior. It just means I remind myself that my first interpretation isn’t necessarily the only one.

2. The Catch & Question Technique

I’ve realized that most judgments happen so fast, I don’t even notice them. They’re reflexive, automatic. So now, when I catch myself forming a quick opinion, I try to pause and ask:

• What am I basing this on?

• Do I actually have enough information?

• Is there another way to look at this?

Sometimes, the answer is still yes, my judgment was fair. But often, I realize I don’t actually know enough to be making a decision yet.

3. The “If Someone Judged Me” Mental Experiment

This one is uncomfortable—but effective.

Whenever I judge someone, I flip the situation and ask:

"If someone judged me based on one interaction, what would they assume?"

• If someone saw me on a bad day, would they assume I’m rude?

• If I was caught in a moment of frustration, would they think I’m short-tempered?

• If I didn’t text back right away, would they assume I don’t care?

This exercise makes me realize how easily I can be misunderstood—and how often I probably misunderstand others, too.

4. Replacing Judgment with Observation

One of the biggest mindset shifts I’ve been trying is this:

👉 Instead of judging, just observe.

Judgment is when I attach a meaning to someone’s action. That person is fake. That person is selfish. That person is trying to impress people.
Observation is when I simply acknowledge what happened, without jumping to conclusions.

• That person smiled a lot during the conversation. (Instead of: That smile was fake.)

• They talked about their achievements. (Instead of: They’re trying to show off.)

• They were quiet and didn’t engage much. (Instead of: They’re cold and unfriendly.)

Observation leaves room for multiple interpretations. It lets me notice behaviors without assigning rigid meanings to them.

5. Practicing Mindfulness to Slow Down Snap Judgments

Most of my judgments come from my subconscious—old habits, mental shortcuts, biases I’ve absorbed over time. The only way to rewire them is to become more aware of them.

Mindfulness helps with this. The next time I catch myself judging someone, I try to:

• Pause. Before reacting, just take a second to notice the thought.

• Label it. Instead of getting caught up in the emotion, I mentally say: Oh, that was a judgment.

• Let it pass. I remind myself that just because I thought something doesn’t mean it’s true.

The more I practice this, the more I realize how much of my judgmental thinking is just background noise—patterns I can choose to break.

Finding the Balance: Openness Without Blind Trust

Letting go of judgment doesn’t mean letting go of boundaries. I’m not trying to force myself to see the best in everyone. Some people are dishonest, self-serving, or untrustworthy. But rather than assuming I already know who someone is, I want to let them show me.

• Instead of immediately deciding someone is fake, I can observe their consistency over time.

• Instead of assuming someone is unreliable, I can watch how they show up in different situations.

• Instead of believing someone is superficial, I can take the time to understand their deeper layers.

I’m not removing discernment. I’m just choosing to slow down my assumptions.

Because at the end of the day, I don’t want to live in a world where I see people through the lens of cynicism and mistrust. I want to stay open. I want to stay curious.

I want to give people the chance to surprise me.

A New Way to See People (And Ourselves)

There’s a certain kind of heaviness that comes with being overly judgmental. It’s subtle, almost unnoticeable at first, but over time, it builds. The more I judge, the more I expect the worst from people. The more I expect the worst, the more disconnected I feel. And the more disconnected I feel, the harder it becomes to see the good in the world around me.

But here’s the truth I’ve been slowly coming to terms with: the way I judge others is a reflection of how I judge myself.

When I assume people are fake, is it because I worry about how I present myself?
When I think people only reach out when they need something, is it because I fear I don’t hold enough value on my own?
When I see someone’s flaws before their strengths, is it because I haven’t learned to extend that same grace to myself?

The way I see others is, in many ways, a mirror. And if I want to shift that lens, I need to start with me.

The Shift: From Judgment to Understanding

I’m not naïve—I know that not everyone is good, and not everyone deserves trust. But I also know that assuming the worst of people doesn’t serve me.

So I’m choosing something different.

I’m choosing to:

• Let people reveal who they are, rather than deciding for them.

• Slow down my snap judgments and replace them with curiosity.

• Observe behavior without immediately attaching meaning to it.

• Hold space for the possibility that I could be wrong.

It’s not about forcing myself to see the world through rose-colored glasses. It’s about allowing space for nuance, for complexity, for the reality that people are more than just a single moment, a single action, or a single impression.

The Challenge: A Small Shift in Perspective

If you’ve read this far, maybe you’ve recognized some of these patterns in yourself too. Maybe you’ve felt the weight of quick judgments, the exhaustion of assuming the worst, the subtle disconnection it creates.

So here’s a challenge. Just for one day, try this:

• Notice every time you make a snap judgment. Pay attention to how quickly your mind assigns labels to people.

• Pause and ask: “Is this the only way to see this?” What other explanations exist?

• Give at least one person the benefit of the doubt. Let them surprise you.

This isn’t about changing overnight. It’s about experimenting with a different way of thinking—one that might just make life a little lighter, a little kinder, and a little more open.

Final Thought: Seeing People as Works in Progress

At the end of the day, I remind myself of this: People are complicated. Messy. Inconsistent. We’re all still figuring things out.

So instead of seeing others through a lens of judgment, I want to see them as works in progress—just like I am. Just like we all are.

Because when I give others grace, I give it to myself too. And that, I think, is a shift worth making.

---